FAM, FIFA & Jalan Ke Depan: Berhenti Berdebat, Mula Membina
FAM, FIFA & Jalan Ke Depan: Berhenti Berdebat, Mula Membina
FIFA menghukum, rayuan dalaman ditolak, perbincangan hangat meletup. Ada yang mahu hentikan di sini, ada yang desak ke CAS, ada yang minta siasatan jenayah. Artikel ini merumuskan realiti undang-undang, menjawab hujah popular, dan cuba mengalih fokus negara kepada perkara yang paling penting: melindungi pemain, membaiki sistem, dan membina semula pembangunan bola sepak Malaysia.
1) Realiti Hari Ini — Bukan Lagi Spekulasi
- FIFA kekalkan denda terhadap FAM; 7 pemain digantung 12 bulan.
- FAM mempertimbang untuk membawa kes ke Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS).
- Kerajaan diingatkan agar berhati-hati: siasatan jenayah boleh, tetapi elakkan “campur tangan” teknikal sukan.
2) Tinjauan Balik: 9 Dakwaan, 9 Jawapan Ringkas
3) Soal Pokok: Nak Ke Mana?
Trek 1 — Undang-undang (CAS)
- Fokuskan hujah pada proses & proportionality.
- Fail lengkap: asal-usul dokumen, rantaian serahan, terjemahan bertauliah, dwi-pengesahan (Legal + Compliance).
Trek 2 — Siasatan Jenayah (Dalam Negeri)
- Buka kertas siasatan jika ada asas pemalsuan—itu bidang kuasa negara, bukan “campur tangan sukan”.
- Gunakan kuasa Pesuruhjaya Sukan (Akta 1997) untuk mewajibkan pendedahan maklumat.
Trek 3 — Perlindungan Pemain & Tadbir Urus
Gaji/kontrak dipelihara (peranan kelab) Sokongan mental & guaman Jurucakap tunggal; kemas kini bertulis mingguan4) Kesan Rantaian ke Ekosistem
5) Jalan Pembetulan 90 Hari
Hari 0–14
- Lantik J/K Bebas (bekas hakim/SC, peguam sukan, forensik dokumen, penterjemah dwibahasa).
- SOP interim: dwi-pengesahan, semak terjemahan, log rantaian dokumen, semakan silang pra-fail.
Hari 15–45
- Kumpul bukti untuk CAS; audit pematuhan berjalan selari.
- Laporan mingguan bertulis; elak “theatre” media.
Hari 46–90
- Siar SOP kekal: borang semak, matriks kelulusan, piawaian dokumen, kalendar FIFA/AFC.
- Dasbor KPI nasional suku tahunan (jurulatih naik taraf, minit U-21, audit dokumen & kewangan).
- Mandat audit bebas tahunan diluluskan EXCO.
6) Lepas Kelayakan — Kembali Pada Pembangunan
a) Laluan Belia (SupaRimau → NFDP/PLD → AMD → Harimau Muda)
- Pastikan minit perlawanan kompetitif minimum per musim bagi setiap umur.
- Liga umur nasional (U-12/14/16/18/20) dengan kalendar tetap & tingkap pemilihan pusat.
- Talent ID berlapis (sekolah–daerah–negeri–AMD) termasuk luar bandar.
b) Standard Jurulatih (AFC/UEFA pathway)
- Peta jalan lesen setara UEFA C/B/A → Pro (kesetaraan AFC) dengan modul tempatan (iklim, saintifik, budaya).
- Sasaran 24 bulan: akademi negeri minimum lesen setara “B”; sekolah zon elit minimum “C”.
- Modul wajib: periodisasi, psikologi prestasi, literasi undang-undang FIFA/AFC, integriti.
c) Ekosistem Sekolah (MOE–FAM–Negeri)
- MOU 3 pihak: padanan jadual liga sekolah & belia; kongsi kemudahan; geran kecil peralatan.
- Program “Coach in School”: penilaian 2× setahun + laporan kepada ibu bapa & sekolah.
d) Tadbir Urus Negeri (KPI, bukan kursi)
- Geran bersyarat KPI: bil. belia, lesen jurulatih, liga pusingan penuh, pendedahan luar.
- Portal keterbukaan: minit mesyuarat, tender, bajet, statistik—suku tahunan.
7) Soalan Yang Patut Mengusik Fikiran
- Jika setiap fail ada dwi-pengesahan, adakah kita sampai ke tahap ini?
- Jika pentadbir & jurulatih diwajibkan modul “FIFA/AFC Law Literacy”, adakah tatacara masih tersilap?
- Jika geran negeri berpaksikan KPI, beranikah kita diaudit suku tahunan secara terbuka?
- Adakah kita melatih pemain untuk bermain dalam sistem, tetapi lupa melatih pentadbir untuk mengurus sistem?
8) Penutup — Berhenti Menuding, Mula Menyusun
- Ke CAS untuk keadilan proses.
- Siasatan jenayah jika ada asas — tanggungjawab negara.
- Lindungi pemain yang bertindak dalam niat baik.
- Tegakkan SOP & KPI — biar silap mati di bilik mesyuarat, bukan meletup di akhbar.
- Kembali kepada pembangunan: jurulatih, liga belia, sekolah, AMD.
Kita tidak ketandusan bakat; kita ketandusan disiplin sistem. Hentikan kitaran malu. Mulakan kitaran maju.
Lampiran A — “Blueprint Pantas” 12 Bulan
- Q1: SOP baharu, jurucakap tunggal, kalender liga umur; 500 jurulatih naik taraf lesen.
- Q2: Dasbor KPI nasional; audit pematuhan pertama; 5 perintis sekolah–kelab.
- Q3: 2,000 jurulatih lulus modul undang-undang sukan; minit U-21 naik 20%.
- Q4: Audit bebas; laporan awam; pembetulan bajet ikut KPI; pakej penaja berasaskan data.
FAM, FIFA & Malaysia’s Crossroads: What We Do After the Storm Will Define Us
FIFA has spoken. Sanctions upheld, reputations bruised, emotions inflamed.
Some say “don’t waste time at CAS”. Others say “fight to the end”.
Some demand criminal investigations. Others just want to protect the players and move on.
This article cuts through the noise. It looks at the law, the ecosystem, and the only question that really matters now:
after this storm, what will Malaysia choose to build?
1) The Storm Has Hit — And the World Is Watching
Malaysia is facing one of the most significant football crises in its modern era.
- FIFA has upheld a fine of around RM1.8 million against FAM.
- Seven heritage players have been suspended for 12 months from all football activities.
- Document falsification was confirmed under Article 22 of the FIFA Disciplinary Code.
The Appeals Committee issued a 64-page judgment — detailed, structured and damning.
FAM insists the documents were lawful under Malaysian administrative procedures.
The National Registration Department (NRD) says the documents it issued are valid under Malaysian law.
But FIFA’s position is clear:
the eligibility documents submitted did not match the “originals” FIFA sourced from foreign registries.
This conflict is no longer just sporting. It is legal. It is procedural. It is reputational.
2) Competing Voices — But Only One Truth Matters
“Don’t go to CAS.”
Former Deputy Law Minister Hanipa Maidin has warned that CAS may not help and could even worsen the situation if FIFA’s evidence and reasoning are strong.
“We must go to CAS.”
TMJ has offered to fund the entire CAS process — legal fees and travel — not just out of pride, but to defend Malaysia’s dignity and protect the players who acted in good faith.
“Investigate criminal wrongdoing.”
Football observers and legal minds argue that document falsification is a crime under national laws, and FIFA does not prohibit governments from probing criminal acts.
“Protect the players first.”
Harimau Malaya CEO Rob Friend has stressed that justice for the players and the integrity of Malaysian football must come before ego battles and media theatre.
They are all partly right. But Malaysia needs a clear, unified path — not scattered panic.
3) The Hard Questions We Must Face
Did FAM’s internal systems fail?
Yes. The FIFA judgment itself points to contradictory documents, weak verification and inconsistent submissions.
Did the players knowingly do anything wrong?
There is no evidence that they did. These players relied entirely on official processes and national bodies. They are now paying the highest price for a system they did not control.
Did the government issue legitimate citizenship documents?
Yes. But citizenship documentation under Malaysian law is not the same test as FIFA’s eligibility criteria. That distinction was ignored until it exploded in our faces.
Did FIFA follow due process?
FIFA claims it did; the Appeals Committee explains why. Whether procedure and proportionality were fair is exactly what the Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS) is meant to review.
4) The Real Risk — CAS Is Not a Magic Wand
CAS is not a political stage. It is a legal arena. Entering it unprepared is dangerous; entering it well-prepared is necessary.
- CAS can uphold the decision.
- CAS can reduce the punishment.
- CAS can even increase sanctions.
- CAS will examine procedural integrity, not social media narratives.
- CAS needs evidence, not emotion.
Going to CAS is not about saving face. It is about clarity, fairness and the long-term credibility of Malaysia as a football nation.
5) Criminal Investigation: Yes, It CAN Proceed
Contrary to public fear, FIFA does not prevent governments from investigating suspected crimes. It only prohibits direct political interference in:
- Team selection
- FA leadership and governance
- Competition management
Criminality is outside FIFA’s jurisdiction. In fact, FIFA has already requested relevant authorities in Malaysia, Argentina, Brazil, Spain and the Netherlands to open investigations.
So the question is simple: if there is nothing to hide, why has no formal criminal investigation begun?
6) Independent Committee vs Real Authority — Know the Difference
FAM’s Internal Independent Committee plays a role, but it has clear limits:
- It cannot compel witnesses beyond FAM’s structures.
- It cannot access foreign civil registries.
- It cannot issue warrants.
- It cannot prosecute or enforce criminal accountability.
That is why the real heavy-lifters must be:
- Royal Malaysia Police (PDRM)
- Ministry of Home Affairs (KDN)
- Malaysian Anti-Corruption Commission (MACC)
- Sports Commissioner’s Office (under the Sports Development Act 1997)
This is no longer “just football paperwork”. It is a question of national integrity, document authenticity, and administrative honesty.
7) The Football Ecosystem Is on the Line
- Malaysian Football League (MFL)
- Amateur Football League (AFL)
- National team matches
- Development programs and academies
- Referee and coaching education
- Broadcasting and sponsorship deals
This crisis is not just a headline. It is a shockwave across an entire economic and social ecosystem.
8) After the Legal Battle — Development Must Come First
No matter what CAS eventually decides, one fact remains: this collapse happened because our development and administrative structures were too weak to prevent it in the first place.
A) Rebuild Youth Development from the Ground Up
On paper, Malaysia already has a pathway:
- SupaRimau Charter (Grassroots 7–12)
- NFDP State Development Centres (13–17)
- Mokhtar Dahari Academy (AMD)
- Harimau Muda (U-16, U-19, U-20 national teams)
But in practice, execution is uneven, fragmented and overly dependent on individuals.
We must:
- Standardise youth development nationwide.
- Audit talent ID and ensure outer regions are not left behind.
- Guarantee a minimum number of competitive match minutes per season for each age group.
- Align school leagues with state and FAM youth calendars.
- Create real pathways beyond sports schools, opening doors to more players and more sponsors.
B) Professionalise Coaching Standards — No More “Half-Baked” Systems
UEFA did not become a powerhouse by luck. Their coaching ladder — from grassroots certificates up to UEFA Pro Licence — is enforced, respected and tied directly to club licensing.
Malaysia must:
- Mandate AFC-equivalent licensing (C, B, A, Pro) for all youth and elite coaches.
- Require periodic renewal and re-certification.
- Introduce compulsory modules:
- FIFA & AFC law literacy
- Ethics and integrity
- Sports psychology and player welfare
- Modern periodisation and performance science
- Ensure every district and state association meets clear minimum coaching standards.
You cannot produce world-class players from third-class coaching structures.
C) Governance Reform — SOP, Audit, Compliance
Every painful headline points back to the same issue: weak systems.
We need:
- Dual verification (Legal + Compliance) for all key documents.
- A national eligibility documentation SOP for FIFA/AFC submissions.
- Quarterly governance dashboards with clear KPIs.
- Annual third-party audits (finance + compliance).
- Full transparency on tenders, hiring and major contracts.
- Zero political interference in technical and operational decisions.
9) Seven Questions Every Sports Body Should Ask Itself
- Is your youth system truly working — or only impressive on PowerPoint?
- Are your administrators trained in international sporting regulations?
- Do your coaches hold real licences — or just honorary certificates?
- Do you track performance KPIs — or do you only track excuses?
- Are your finances and decisions transparent to your stakeholders?
- Can your state or association produce talent consistently — or only by accident?
- If your system collapsed tomorrow, do you have a backup plan?
These questions are not just for football. They apply to every sport and every association in Malaysia.
10) A 90-Day Survival & Recovery Blueprint
Days 0–30
- Appoint a genuine Independent Commission (retired judge + international sports law experts).
- Submit CAS notice of appeal with clear strategy.
- Begin full compliance and forensic documentation audit.
- Initiate criminal investigation where there is legal basis.
- Issue weekly written updates to the public.
Days 31–60
- Complete document mapping and reconstruction of all eligibility files.
- Rebuild SOPs for verification, translation and certification.
- Launch training for admins and coaches on FIFA/AFC legal frameworks.
Days 61–90
- Publish national development KPIs for each state FA.
- Align national youth pathway and league calendars.
- Announce enforcement steps for non-compliance.
- Begin annual independent audit cycle.
11) Final Message — After the Storm, We Are Judged by What We Do Next
Malaysia now stands at a fork in the road.
Option A:
- Blame everyone else.
- Deny, deflect, delay.
- Protect positions instead of principles.
Option B:
- Own the failure.
- Protect the players.
- Fix the system, not just the headlines.
- Rebuild development, coaching and governance.
- Use CAS to clarify, not to perform.
- Turn a scandal into a blueprint for reform.
In football and in life, greatness is not defined by the absence of storms. It is defined by our response when the storm passes.
After a storm, what we do next is how we are judged.
Comments